How to Write Criminal Law Case Studies

Filter by Category
Latest News
Date Archive
Archives
Leaders in Law

How to Write Criminal Law Case Studies

Criminal law case studies examine the practical application of legal principles in individual cases. They study case law that supports or attacks the client’s position and circumstances. They look for facts that would encourage leniency or a stiff sentence. Criminal law case study writing can provide supplemental income for legal professionals.

Some Examples of Criminal Law Case Studies

Facing criminal charges, a project manager might pay for a case study that casts the company actions in a more positive light. That case study would focus on criminal law decisions that support their defense. It would also include information that focused on the accused manager’s redeeming qualities and justified or explained their failings.

A human rights organization seeking to draw attention to wartime atrocities might fund a war crimes case study. That study would rely on eyewitness and survivor testimonies and cite national and international law cases. It would identify perpetrators and document their participation in war crimes. 

Benefits of Criminal Law Studies

Criminal law is shaped by societal shifts, landmark rulings, and the details of individual cases. Case studies help you understand the way laws evolve. An in-depth examination of a case teaches you how the justice system operates. Here are some ways that criminal case law studies can benefit lawyers and non-lawyers alike.

Deeper Understanding of Criminal Law in Action

Law students often learn about criminal law through reading statutes and decisions. While these are important, they downplay other factors that influence criminal cases. Case studies show how these legal questions play out in the real world. 

A judge’s decision is only one part of a criminal justice trial. Arresting officers, witnesses, prosecutors, jurors, witnesses, and defendants all play a role in how a case plays out – or if it goes to trial at all. By recognizing the role they play in the trial, a student learns how to better defend a client or prosecute a case. 

Development of Critical Thinking Skills

In studying criminal law, students learn to distinguish between relevant and irrelevant facts. They use that knowledge to shape a narrative to their benefit. Prosecutors can determine which laws were broken. Defense attorneys can challenge whether those laws apply in the situation at hand.

According to Ethan Parker, a Studybay educational expert, “Case studies give you a better understanding of how the case might have gone differently. Case studies encourage law students to examine alternative approaches, strategies, and outcomes. They provide insight into the decision-making processes of the judges and others involved in the case. And they can point to moments when different arguments might have succeeded where the original failed.” 

Putting Case Law Into Proper Context

While case law relies on precedent, case studies put the precedent in context. Let’s look at Oliver Wendell Holmes’ famous 1919 comment about falsely shouting fire in a crowded theater. In 1911 a false shout of “fire” in an opera house led to a panic in which 26 people were killed and 50 seriously injured. In 1913, someone shouted “fire” at a meeting hall where striking miners and their families were celebrating Christmas Eve. 73 people died in that stampede, most of them children. 

We also learn that Holmes used his “fire” analogy to uphold the sentence of anti-war activist Charles Schenck. And we discover that Schenck vs United States was overruled by Brandenburg vs Ohio (1969). 

What You Need to Know To Write Criminal Law Case Studies

There is a definite interest in criminal law case studies. Law students often seek help in analyzing and writing criminal law case studies. You’ll often find case studies used in continuing legal professional education courses. And there’s a growing demand for analysts with the critical skills required to write criminal law case studies. 

The skills required to write criminal law case studies include: 

A Strong Understanding of Criminal Law

You need to grasp some important ideas in criminal law, including but not limited to:

  • Actus Reus (Criminal Act): A crime requires a voluntary physical act or a lawful omission when you have a duty to act. 
  • Mens Rea (Criminal Intent): You need to understand the legal definitions of intent, knowledge, recklessness, and negligence. 
  • Concurrence: Were the criminal act and criminal intent present at the same time. 
  • Accomplice Liability and Vicarious Liability: For example, if three people commit a felony and one of them kills a person during the act, all three can be charged and convicted of murder. You can also be charged with aiding and abetting a crime.
  • Crimes Against Persons: Murder, sexual assault, kidnapping, armed robbery.
  • Crimes Against Property: Burglary, theft, embezzlement, arson.
  • Justification Defenses: A justification defenses claim the defendant’s behavior was justified or does not fit the charge.
  • Excuse defenses: An excuse defense acknowledges the defendant committed the crime but cites mitigating circumstances.

Legal Research Skills

You need to be comfortable working with databases like Westlaw, Pacer, and Lexis. You also have to know how to write and understand legal citations. And you must be able to locate, read, and interpret criminal statutes. 

You must also be able to

  • identify key legal issues,
  • find the relevant facts, and
  • use them to support or undermine a legal argument. 

Excellent Writing Skills

Lawyers are notorious for being long-winded and speaking in jargon. But case studies must be written in clear, concise language. If you must use legal terminology, you should be able to explain what it is and how it applies to the case at hand. You must also know how to tailor your language for the intended audience. 

Not only do you have to write clearly. Your case study must be well-organized and show your ability to build a compelling legal argument. You must present facts logically and show how different legal principles apply. Your writing should guide the reader through your analysis and lead them to a well-supported conclusion. 

Writing criminal law case studies isn’t easy, but it can be rewarding. A criminal law case study can be both educational and entertaining. And the skills you learn in writing case studies are applicable not just to the legal field. You can also use them in many other fields. Critical thinking skills and the ability to sift relevant from irrelevant facts are always in high demand.

1596448181560
Forgot password?

No worries, let’s reset the password now.

1596448181560
Welcome back!

Please enter your details.

Get in Touch

Lead Contact Form